Not every restaurant in Cape Coral lives up to expectations.
Based on local feedback gathered from Reddit, here's a list of the most disappointing dining spots in the city and what makes them fall short.
Buffalo Wild Wings
Many locals on Reddit expressed disappointment with Buffalo Wild Wings, citing poor food quality and subpar service.
If you're craving wings, this may not be the best spot to satisfy your appetite.
Wingnuts
Wingnuts garnered criticism for watery frozen wings, inconsistent service, and additional charges for basic condiments like ranch. One reviewer summed it up as “wet garbage.”
Bubba’s Roadhouse
Bubba’s Roadhouse was a repeat offender in the Reddit thread. Many described it as dirty, dark, and lacking flavor.
Some even mentioned questionable food storage practices and rats in the ceiling.
I have been here myself and didn't find the food very good and wouldn't go back.
Ariani Italian
While Ariani Italian boasts a reputation for authentic cuisine, some diners found it disappointing.
Complaints included below-average food, poor service, and an overly hyped wine selection that turned out to be a basic $8 bottle of Riesling.
Golden Corral
This buffet chain made the list for being shut down in the past and for food quality issues. A Redditor humorously mentioned "rat chili" as a reason to steer clear.
Lobster Lady
Despite its popularity, Lobster Lady left many diners unimpressed.
Complaints ranged from poor service during special events to subpar California rolls made with undercooked rice. One diner even reported food poisoning from the linguine with clam sauce.
Personally, I didn't think it was terrible but given the choice, I would go elsewhere.
Anthony’s on the Boulevard
Anthony’s on the Boulevard faced harsh criticism for its food quality. Many described it as an outdated dining option with little to offer in terms of flavor or atmosphere.
South Cape Café
The South Cape Café earned a spot on this list for its bland and poorly prepared breakfast offerings.
Allegations of it being a meeting spot for questionable groups added to its negative reputation.
Monarca’s
Monarca’s Mexican cuisine failed to impress diners, with many labeling it as absolutely terrible in both food quality and service.
Marker 92
Located at the Westin Resort, Marker 92 was criticized for being overpriced with mediocre food.
Some locals felt it catered more to tourists than to residents seeking a quality dining experience.
Stevie Tomato’s
Stevie Tomato’s was noted for its rowdy environment and subpar food.
One diner mentioned having their experience ruined by a drunk patron loudly bragging about his past TV appearances.
Keke’s Breakfast Café
Keke’s made the list due to an incident involving multiple plates of food containing long black hairs.
While the meals were comped, the experience left diners vowing never to return.
Chicago Pizza
Chicago Pizza was deemed "horrible" by Redditors, with many citing poor taste and low-quality ingredients.
Conclusion
While Cape Coral has plenty of great dining options, some restaurants fail to deliver.
Use these reviews to guide your dining choices and ensure your meals are memorable for the right reasons.
