When it comes to pizza in Cape Coral, Florida, Nice Guys Pizza offers more than just a meal—it delivers a truly unforgettable experience.
Known for their unique pizza creations, laid-back vibe, and inventive menu, Nice Guys has earned its reputation as a must-visit destination for foodies and pizza lovers alike.
Outside Nice Guys Pizza, back entrance
Where Creativity Meets Pizza
Nice Guys Pizza isn’t your average pizza joint. They specialize in crafting unconventional pizzas that push the boundaries of flavor.
From classic combinations to bold, unexpected pairings, their menu is a playground for adventurous eaters. Whether you’re craving a traditional margherita or something daring like their famous mac-and-cheese-topped pizza, Nice Guys has something for everyone.
Menu Highlights
Starters
- Dank Nugz: Bite-sized butter pretzels served with charred jalapeño cheese dip.
- Garlic Knots: Made with house herb butter, garlic, and parmesan.
- Cool Ranch Tots: Tater tots seasoned with cool ranch, served with chimichurri and sriracha crema.
- Cheese Styxx: House-made cheesy breadsticks perfect for sharing.
- Stinky Buns: Build-your-own pork buns with black garlic, gochujang hoisin, and kimchi.
Signature Pizzas
Hot Honey Pizza at Nice Guys Pizza
- The Big Mick Pizza: Inspired by the iconic burger, featuring all beef, special sauce, lettuce, cheese, pickles, onions, and a sesame seed crust.
- Black Gold: A luxurious mix of black garlic, seasonal fruit, pistachio basil pesto, gorgonzola, and prosciutto.
- Chicken Pizza Masala: Garlic butter, tikka masala sauce, mozzarella, and chicken topped with cilantro.
- The Carnivore: Loaded with bacon, pepperoni, ham, housemade sausage, and mozzarella on a red sauce base.
- Street Corn Named Desire: Corn, mozzarella, parmesan, citrus garlic aioli, and cilantro.
- Hot Honey: Featuring hot honey drizzle, prosciutto, salami, and a trio of cheeses.
Vegan Options
- Vegan Truffle Shuffle: Black truffle oil, cremini mushrooms, red onion, and vegan cheese.
- Vegan General Tso's Pizza: Vegan chicken, broccoli, pineapple, and General Tso’s sauce.
- Vegan Herbivore: Packed with mushrooms, black olives, onions, peppers, banana peppers, and vegan cheese on a red sauce base.
Desserts
- Deep Fried Oreos: Served with house jam for a sweet finish.
- Euro Trash Doughnuts: Fluffy, fried doughnuts paired with house jam.
A Quirky Atmosphere
Inside bar at Nice Guys Pizza
What sets Nice Guys Pizza apart isn’t just the food—it’s the vibe. The restaurant’s eclectic decor and laid-back ambiance make it a fun and inviting place to hang out.
With local artwork, retro touches, and an atmosphere that feels like home, it’s easy to see why Nice Guys is a favorite among Cape Coral locals.
Events and Entertainment
In addition to serving up incredible food, Nice Guys frequently hosts live music, trivia nights, and other community events. There are pinball machines in the lounge as well.
It’s not just a restaurant—it’s a gathering place where friends and families come together to enjoy great food and good company.
Why Nice Guys Pizza is a Cape Coral Favorite
Outside mural of Nice Guys Pizza
Nice Guys Pizza combines bold flavors, a welcoming atmosphere, and a commitment to creativity that keeps customers coming back.
Whether you’re a local or just visiting Cape Coral, a trip to Nice Guys Pizza promises to be a highlight of your dining adventures.
Stop by Nice Guys Pizza today and see why it’s more than just a meal—it’s an experience that’ll have you coming back for more.
Details
Website: niceguyspizza.com
Address: 1404 Cape Coral Parkway East, Cape Coral, FL 33904
